Sunday, May 13, 2012

Mother and Child: An Off-Screen Role


An actress, according to some, is more than merely a woman. Many actresses have tried to avoid playing mothers, perhaps in recognition that it means that Father Time is passing by and that typecasting is a distinct possibility. On screen during the studio era mothers were practically enshrined as paragons of unselfishness, but the complex reality behind the screen gradually filtered in. By mid-century, when the fear of "Momism" was prevalent in popular culture, along with some simplified Freudian notions of a mother's role in shaping her children, mothers became positively toxic in some instances (see Tennessee Williams' film versions of The Glass Menagerie and Suddenly, Last Summer, among others).

Off-screen, however, the reality of balancing private and public lives became even trickier as women who had pursued a career could not help hearing biology's siren call. Some public women became great Moms, others were less fortunate in that their failures within their families became public fodder. None of us can choose our mothers, nor can they really choose us...most of the time (certain well known stars adoption practices seemed to belie this). 

Both mother and child are surprised, wounded, delighted, and irrevocably shaped by the way we change each other. Among the women who took the once radical step of going on the stage and later the screen some had stage mothers but some eventually just wanted to follow that powerful visceral call and follow social norms by having a family, which could not have been easy. Sometimes this arrangement worked out well, no doubt helped somewhat by nannies that success made affordable),  but the glaring examples of children of fame whose lives did not pan out overshadow the majority of kids who survived having a mother who was constantly being treated like a creature from Mount Olympus in public. The magazines that published these pictures way back when were a necessary evil for most of these working women, who needed the publicity to continue their career...or so it was believed. These Moms were fortunate enough to be able to control the images of themselves and their most vulnerable family members in an era before microscopic examination of every flaw became the press' bread and butter. If we could ask Mary Astor, Lana Turner or some of the other ladies below how they really felt about being captured on film with their offspring, I suspect their replies might be bittersweet at best.

Below the break is a collection of thumbnail images capturing some familiar women in uncharacteristic roles as real life mothers with children, as well as those celebrated adults in the company of their Mom. Each of these captured moments seems  fraught with tenderness, awkwardness, and inescapable reality. I've included pictures that appealed to me for just those reasons along with those that underlined the human roots of life before and beyond the silver screen.

Enjoy and please click on the thumbnails to see the enlarged pictures with more info about the subjects.




Shirley Temple & daughter


Mary Astor & children

June Allyson & children





Ann Sothern & daughter


Jean Simmons & family


Jennifer Jones & sons



Ingrid Bergman & twins


Margaret Sullavan & daughters

Jill Esmond & son




Rita Hayworth & children


Norma Shearer & family


Loretta Young & daughter



Frances Dee & son


Lupita Tovar & family

Hedy Lamarr & children



Ida Lupino & family


Joan Fontaine & daughters

Betty Grable & daughters


Mickey Rooney with Mother Deborah Kerr & family Liberace & mom


Joan Bennett & daughters Warner Baxter & mother Greta Garbo & mother


Claudette Colbert & mother Douglas Fairbanks Jr. & mother Bette Davis & mother


Joanne Dru & son Ginger Rogers & mother Kay Spreckels Gable & son


Betsy Blair & family Joan Blondell & children Maureen O'Sullivan & family

5 comments:

Jacqueline T Lynch said...

These are great. Especially like the one with Jennifer Jones and boys at piano.

Moira Finnie said...

Thanks, Jacqueline.

I hoped others would enjoy them. I think my favorites are the one with Ann Sothern fly-fishing with her daughter and fellow actress Tisha Sterling (her Dad was Robert Sterling) and my other fave is Ingrid and her twins. She looks a bit tired but game and the babies are all set for an adventure.

I really appreciate your taking the time to comment.

knitwit said...

Great piece (as usual) Moira! The pictures tell some interesting stories, don't they? I especially love the Ann Southern and Betsy Blair photos.

Moira Finnie said...

Thanks, knitty! I also thought it was possible to feel the sense of fun emanating from Ann Sothern and her daughter in that photo. As for the image of Betsy Blair and family--the look on Kelly's face as he gazes at Betsy and the alert little baby just radiates love far more than expected. I really appreciate your taking the time to post a comment. See you around the squirrel cage at the SSO, friend. ;-)

Cheers,
Moira

KimWilson said...

Nice pics. I think a lot of actresses had children for one particular reason: to believe that someone loved them for who they were, not how the world perceived them. Some, obviously, shouldn't have been mothers, but many turned out to be great at it. Still, the world was a simpler place back then with a press that could be controlled somewhat.

LinkWithin

Related Posts with Thumbnails